Excerpt with Comments

Morgan Hill Unified School District Mathematics Content Standards

Algebra I

The following excerpt is from the MHUSD Math Standards approved unanimously by the School Board on June 14, 1999. The Standards cover K through 12; this excerpt includes only the standard for Algebra I. It is part of the standards for Grades 8-12, which are arranged by discipline, not grade.

The contrast in quality between the state standards and the District additions is immediately apparent, where the state standards are logically ordered, definite, measurable, and specific. The District additions, by contrast, are not ordered logically (the letter numbering is not in the original but was supplied for comment purposes) and in comparison are indefinite, unmeasurable, and non-specific. Also, the District additions mostly overlap with the state standards, and, contrary to the claims of the District, only occasionally exceed the state requirements, more often falling short.

- Comments by Robert Harrington, January 25, 1999

State Standards
(contains a few inconsequential editorial changes from state document)

Symbolic reasoning and calculations with symbols are central in algebra. In the study of algebra a student develops an understanding of the symbolic language of mathematics and the sciences. In addition algebraic skills and concepts are developed and used in a wide variety of problem solving situations.

1. Students identify and use the arithmetic properties of subsets of integers, rational, irrational and real numbers. This includes closure properties for the four basic arithmetic operations where applicable.

1.1 Students use properties of numbers to demonstrate that assertions are true or false.

2. Students understand and use such operations as taking the opposite. reciprocal, raising to a power, and taking a root. This includes the understanding and use of the rules of exponents.

3. Students solve equations and inequalities involving absolute values.

4. Students simplify expressions prior to solving linear equations and inequalities in one variable such as 3(2x-5) + 4(x-2) = 12.

5. Students solve multi-step problems, including word problems, involving linear equations and linear inequalities in one variable, with justification of each step.

6. Students graph a linear equation, and compute the x- and y- intercepts (e.g., graph 2x -t 6y = 4). They are also able to sketch the region defined by linear inequality (e.g., sketch the region defined by 2x + 6y < 4)

7. Students verify that a point lies on a line given an equation of the line. Students are able to derive linear equations using the point-slope formula.

8. Students understand the concepts of parallel and perpendicular lines and how their slopes are related. Students are able to find the equation of a line perpendicular to a given line that passes through a given point.

9. Students solve a system of two linear equations in two variables algebraically, and are able to interpret the answer graphically. Students are able to use this to solve a system of two linear inequalities in two variables, and to sketch the solution sets.

10. Students add, subtract, multiply and divide monomials and polynomials. Students solve multistep problems, including word problems, using these techniques.

11. Students apply basic factoring techniques to second and simple third degree polynomials. These techniques include finding a common factor to all of the terms in a polynomial and recognizing the difference of two squares, and recognizing perfect squares of binomials.

12. Students simplify fractions with polynomials in the numerator and denominator by factoring both and reducing to lowest terms.

13. Students add, subtract, multiply, and divide rational expressions and functions. Students solve both computationally and conceptually challenging problems using these techniques.

14. Students solve a quadratic equation by factoring or completing the square.

15. Students apply algebraic techniques to rate problems work problems, and percent mixture problems.

16. Students understand the concepts of a relation and a function, determine whether a given relation defines a function, and give pertinent information about given relations and functions.

17. Students determine the domain of independent variables, and range of dependent variables defined by a graph, a set of ordered pairs, or symbolic expression.

18. Students determine whether a relation defined by a graph, a set of ordered pairs, or symbolic expression is a function and justify the conclusion.

19. Students know the quadratic formula and are familiar with its proof by completing the square.

20. Students use the quadratic formula to find the roots of a second degree polynomial and to solve quadratic equations.

21. Students graph quadratic functions and know that their roots are the intercepts.

22. Students use the quadratic formula and/or factoring techniques to determine whether the graph of a quadratic function will intersect the x-axis in zero, one, or two points.

23. Students apply quadratic equations to physical problems such as the motion of an object under the force of gravity.

24. Students use and know simple aspects of a logical argument.

24.1 Students explain the difference between inductive and deductive reasoning and identify and provide examples of each.

24.2 Students identify the hypothesis and conclusion in logical deduction.

24.3 Students use counterexamples to show that an assertion is false and recognize that a single counterexample is sufficient to refute an assertion.

25. Students use properties of the number system to judge the validity of results, to justify each step of a procedure and to prove or disprove statements.

25.1 Students use properties of numbers to construct simple valid arguments (direct and indirect) for, or formulate counterexamples to, claimed assertions.

25.2 Students judge the validity of an argument based on whether the properties of the real number system and order of operations have been applied correctly at each step.

25.3 Given a specific algebraic statement involving linear, quadratic or absolute value expressions, equations or inequalities, students determine if the statement is true sometimes, always, or never.

District Additions

a. Students identify and use the arithmetic properties of real numbers to solve and justify multi-step problems

b. Students represent equations and inequalities as graphs, use graphs to solve problems, and illlustrate, approximate and verify solutions

c. Students understand the meaning simultaneous linear equations and their solulions, and use them to solve problems

d. Students understand how to simplify algebraic expressions including radicals using basic operations

e. Students relate quadratic expressions, equations and graphs to characteristics of linear expressions, equations and graphs, and understand contexts in which quadratic models arise

f. Students use strategies, skills and concepts in finding solutions

g. Students expand their understanding of the appropriate uses of a scientific calculator

h. Students model real-world phenomena with a variety of functions

i. Students use probabiiity and apply it to real life situations

Comments on District Additions

a. Redundant; see State Standard 25.1 and 25.2

b. Redundant; see 6 and 9

c. Redundant; see 9

d. Redundant; see 4 and 12

e. Redundant with 21, 22, and 23, except for "and understand contexts in which quadratic models arise"

f. Vague

g. Non-content

h. Vague

i. Belongs in Probability and Statistics (standards for Grades 8-12 are arranged under discipline headings)